First pass
Land at Lower Broad Oak Road, West Hill
East Devon District Council, EX11 1XH
Although outside the West Hill built-up area boundary, the land is considered worth pursuing because the council cannot show a five-year supply, which opens Framework policy S5(1)(j) to a site well-related to the village.
Sources: 3.16 years at 07/10/2026, appeal-planning-decision.service.gov.uk/published-documen...; National Planning Policy Framework, August 2026, assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6a8334c03bd75b81e2...; decision letter APP/U1105/W/24/3357250, paragraphs 6 and 10, 11/08/2025
The three blockers
- The land is outside the West Hill built-up area boundary, so it conflicts with Strategy 7 of the East Devon Local Plan and Policy NP1 of the Ottery St Mary and West Hill Neighbourhood Plan.
- Trees on the hedges are protected by a confirmed Tree Preservation Order.
- It has been suggested that a covenant on the land would be breached by the development.
What the land is worth
In the Full Pass
The land value range, worked from sold prices and every cost, and the full financial appraisal as an Excel workbook.
What the Full Pass addsThe conditions
- The houses are placed and sized so that the Policy NP6 view from Lower Broad Oak Road over the sloping fields towards East Hill and the Sidmouth Gap remains readable in the background.
- The protected trees and the hedgerows used by foraging bats are kept intact, and the slow worms on the site are either given retained grassland or moved under a translocation scheme.
- The council accepts that five homes on about 1.5 ha attract no affordable housing, although the site meets the 0.5 ha limb of its Affordable Housing SPD (figure 3.1, adopted 25/11/2020).
The site
- Two adjoining grazing fields, about 1.5 hectares, sloping down from the road to the east
- Hedges with trees under a preservation order on every boundary except the southern one
- Existing houses to the north, south and east, and along the far side of Lower Broad Oak Road
- The field gate on Lower Broad Oak Road, the existing way in
- The view protected by the neighbourhood plan, from the gate across the land towards East Hill
In a real first pass this is an aerial photograph with the title boundary drawn on it. For a public example the site is drawn as a sketch from the description in the appeal decision, not to scale.
The evidence behind this page
Every point above, in full, with what would settle it, who settles it, roughly what that costs and where each fact comes from.
Conditions of the Pursue
- The houses are placed and sized so that the Policy NP6 view from Lower Broad Oak Road over the sloping fields towards East Hill and the Sidmouth Gap remains readable in the background.A landscape-led layout that keeps every hedge and tree, sets the houses down the slope at a low height and holds a view corridor from the field gate.Settled by: A landscape architect, then East Devon District Council as local planning authority on the application and at reserved matters.
- The protected trees and the hedgerows used by foraging bats are kept intact, and the slow worms on the site are either given retained grassland or moved under a translocation scheme.Access through the existing field gate with minimal widening, and reptile and great crested newt measures from an updated ecological impact assessment. Dark corridors of open grassland 5 m wide on each side of the hedges, kept outside private gardens, as the Devon County Council guidance cited by the council requires (decision letter paragraph 19, 11/08/2025).Settled by: An ecologist, then East Devon District Council as local planning authority.
- The council accepts that five homes on about 1.5 ha attract no affordable housing, although the site meets the 0.5 ha limb of its Affordable Housing SPD (figure 3.1, adopted 25/11/2020).Written pre-application advice on the point before any price is agreed, because an on-site requirement at the 50% Strategy 34 target for West Hill would reduce the land value materially (Affordable Housing SPD figure 3.2, 2020).Settled by: East Devon District Council as local planning authority.
The blockers in full
- 1
The land is outside the West Hill built-up area boundary, so it conflicts with Strategy 7 of the East Devon Local Plan and Policy NP1 of the Ottery St Mary and West Hill Neighbourhood Plan. The East Devon Villages Plan describes patchy footways and long walking routes in the village, so the scheme also conflicts with Strategy 5B and Policy TC2 on reaching facilities without a car. Policy NP6 protects the view across the fields from Lower Broad Oak Road towards East Hill and the Sidmouth Gap, and houses in the foreground could obscure at least part of it, depending on their height and position. The emerging East Devon Local Plan 2020 to 2042 did not propose to allocate the site at its Regulation 19 stage, and it had not been adopted by 07/10/2026 (decision letter paragraph 31, 11/08/2025; appeal 6013380, paragraph 14, 07/10/2026).
- What would settle it
- A landscape and visual appraisal with a layout drawn to keep the view, and a walking-route assessment to the shop, school and bus stops, so that the harm can be weighed against five new homes.
- Who settles it
- A landscape architect and a transport planner, then East Devon District Council as local planning authority.
- Rough cost
- £2,000 to £10,000
Source: acp.planninginspectorate.gov.uk/ViewDocument.aspx?fileid=... (decision letter APP/U1105/W/24/3357250, paragraphs 5, 7, 10 to 13, 16 and 27 to 31, 11/08/2025) and appeal-planning-decision.service.gov.uk/published-documen... (appeal 6013380, paragraph 14, 07/10/2026), read 23 October 2026
- 2
Trees on the hedges are protected by a confirmed Tree Preservation Order. Surveys in 2023 recorded at least ten bat species foraging along the hedgerows and a high number of slow worms across the grassland. The evidence also suggests that the site lies in a great crested newt consultation zone, within 500 m of two ponds.
- What would settle it
- An updated ecological impact assessment that covers the spring season, with a baseline under the statutory biodiversity metric, and a layout that keeps every hedge and tree with access through the existing gateway.
- Who settles it
- An ecologist and an arboriculturist, then East Devon District Council as local planning authority.
- Rough cost
- £2,000 to £10,000
Source: acp.planninginspectorate.gov.uk/ViewDocument.aspx?fileid=... (decision letter APP/U1105/W/24/3357250, paragraphs 6, 17, 18, 21 and 23, 11/08/2025), read 23 October 2026
- 3
It has been suggested that a covenant on the land would be breached by the development. Its terms and whether it can still be enforced are not known, and a planning permission would not release the land from any covenant that still binds it.
- What would settle it
- The official copy of the title register and the deed that created the covenant, read by a solicitor, then a negotiated release if it is still enforceable.
- Who settles it
- A solicitor acting for the buyer.
- Rough cost
- £500 to £2,000
Source: acp.planninginspectorate.gov.uk/ViewDocument.aspx?fileid=... (decision letter APP/U1105/W/24/3357250, paragraph 38, 11/08/2025), read 23 October 2026
Sources
- acp.planninginspectorate.gov.uk/ViewDocument.aspx?fileid=...
- acp.planninginspectorate.gov.uk/ViewCase.aspx?caseid=3357250
- landregistry.data.gov.uk/app/ppd
- find-energy-certificate.service.gov.uk/
- api.postcodes.io/
- web.archive.org/web/20240807232326/https://eastdevon.gov....
- web.archive.org/web/20240612021900/https://eastdevon.gov....
- easthants.gov.uk/sites/default/files/2026-01/CIL%20Indexa...
- web.archive.org/web/20260502191851/https://democracy.east...
- web.archive.org/web/20240112153104/https://eastdevon.gov....
- gov.uk/guidance/building-safety-levy-guidance/section-1-i...
- bcis.co.uk/news/latest-movement-in-the-private-housing-co...
- gov.uk/guidance/viability
- bankofengland.co.uk/monetary-policy/the-interest-rate-ban...
- appeal-planning-decision.service.gov.uk/published-documen...
- assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6a8334c03bd75b81e2...
- gov.uk/guidance/national-planning-policy-framework-annex-...
- gov.uk/guidance/biodiversity-net-gain
- acp.planninginspectorate.gov.uk/ViewDocument.aspx?fileid=...
What was decided
East Devon District Council refused outline permission. On 11 August 2025 a planning inspector allowed the appeal and granted outline permission for five homes. The Inspector found that the harm to the character of the area and to the valued view did not significantly and demonstrably outweigh the benefit of five homes, while the council could show only 2.7 years of housing land. Read the decision (APP/U1105/W/24/3357250).