First pass
Land adjacent to Swan House Tea Room, Cone Valley, Woolaston, Lydney
Forest of Dean District Council, GL15 6AD
It is considered that the scheme should not be pursued, because the bat and estuary pollution mitigation this site is likely to need would have to be secured by condition, which permission in principle cannot carry.
The three blockers
- Article 5B of the Town and Country Planning (Permission in Principle) Order 2017, as amended, bars permission in principle for habitats development.
- The officer report places the site about 3.6 km from the nearest part of the Wye Valley and Forest of Dean Bat SAC and within 300 m of three roosts functionally linked to it.
- The site is inside the zone of influence of the Severn Estuary SAC, SPA and Ramsar sites, which the council sets at 6.2 km.
What the land is worth
In the Full Pass
The land value range, worked from sold prices and every cost, and the full financial appraisal as an Excel workbook.
What the Full Pass addsThe site
- The site
- Three roosts linked to the protected bat site, within 300 metres
- The 3 km lesser and greater horseshoe roost zones in the council's 2021 bat guidance
- The Wye Valley and Forest of Dean bat site itself, 3.6 km away
- All of it inside the zone where new homes add visitors to the Severn Estuary's protected sites
In a real first pass this is an aerial photograph with the title boundary drawn on it. For a public example the site is drawn as a diagram from the facts in the appeal decision, not to scale.
The evidence behind this page
Every point above, in full, with what would settle it, who settles it, roughly what that costs and where each fact comes from.
The blockers in full
- 1
Article 5B of the Town and Country Planning (Permission in Principle) Order 2017, as amended, bars permission in principle for habitats development. That is development likely to have a significant effect on a European site, for which the competent authority has not given consent under regulation 63 of the Conservation of Habitats and Species Regulations 2017. Government guidance allows a grant only where an appropriate assessment, taking account of mitigation, concludes that the scheme will not adversely affect the integrity of the site. A grant of permission in principle cannot carry conditions or planning obligations, so mitigation that depends on either cannot be secured through it.
- What would settle it
- Permission in principle would need an appropriate assessment able to conclude no adverse effect on either site without relying on conditions. On this site, which is bounded by woodland and lies inside two horseshoe bat survey zones, that conclusion is unlikely. A full or outline application, which can carry conditions, is the realistic alternative and would be assessed on its merits. The location and the number of homes are not tested in this pass. No published fee was found for the surveys and the application, so the cost band is an estimate.
- Who settles it
- Forest of Dean District Council, as local planning authority and as competent authority under the Habitats Regulations.
- Rough cost
- over £10,000
Source: Article 5B(1) and 5B(5) of the Order as quoted in paragraph 2, and paragraphs 10 and 14, of decision 6005801 on application P1500/25/PIP, appeal-planning-decision.service.gov.uk/comment-planning-... (read 23/10/2026). Planning Practice Guidance on permission in principle, Paragraphs 005, 020 and 022 (Reference IDs 58-005-20190315, 58-020-20180615 and 58-022-20180615), gov.uk/guidance/permission-in-principle (read 23/10/2026)., read 23 October 2026
- 2
The officer report places the site about 3.6 km from the nearest part of the Wye Valley and Forest of Dean Bat SAC and within 300 m of three roosts functionally linked to it. The site is a compound bounded by woodland, inside the 3 km lesser horseshoe maternity buffer and the 3 km greater horseshoe hibernation area in the council's July 2021 guidance. Read against that guidance, it is a very sensitive location for lesser horseshoe bats and a highly sensitive location for greater horseshoe bats. No Preliminary Ecological Appraisal accompanied the application.
- What would settle it
- A Preliminary Ecological Appraisal, then horseshoe bat activity surveys to the council's guidance. For a very sensitive location the guidance asks for at least 35 days of automated detector survey between April and October, ten evening transects and, generally, winter survey as well. A full season may be avoided only where an ecologist's statement shows the impacts are minor and can be avoided or mitigated without harm to the bat habitat of the SAC. The results would inform the council's appropriate assessment, and any mitigation they show is needed would have to be secured by condition. No published fee was found for this survey work, so the cost band is an estimate.
- Who settles it
- An ecologist, then Forest of Dean District Council as competent authority.
- Rough cost
- over £10,000
Source: Paragraph 4 of decision 6005801, which reports the officer report's distances, and paragraphs 7 to 9, which read the site against the council's guidance, appeal-planning-decision.service.gov.uk/comment-planning-... (read 23/10/2026). The council's interim horseshoe bat survey and assessment guidance of July 2021, Tables 1 and 2 and pages 9 to 11, fdean.gov.uk/media/q1jnfo54/wv-fod-bat-sac-development-ma..., read 23 October 2026
- 3
The site is inside the zone of influence of the Severn Estuary SAC, SPA and Ramsar sites, which the council sets at 6.2 km. More residents would add recreational pressure on the estuary, and the scheme could affect its water environment. Pollution prevention would need a condition, which a grant of permission in principle cannot carry. The recreation contribution can be secured by a s.111 agreement under the council's strategy, but nothing was in place to secure it.
- What would settle it
- The council's strategic contribution of £286 a home at the July 2023 rate, rising with the consumer prices index, plus a £125 fee, under a s.111 agreement sent with the application. Pollution prevention would be secured by condition on a full or outline application. The council's page says the approach and the zone are under review by the Gloucestershire councils with Natural England. Read on 23/10/2026, the page still gives later in 2024 as the time for changes, so the rate and the zone should be confirmed with the council.
- Who settles it
- Forest of Dean District Council as competent authority.
- Rough cost
- £500 to £2,000
Source: Paragraphs 5 and 14 of decision 6005801, appeal-planning-decision.service.gov.uk/comment-planning-... (read 23/10/2026), and the council's Severn Estuary habitats page, fdean.gov.uk/planning-and-building/wildlife-and-biodivers... (read 23/10/2026), read 23 October 2026
Sources
- appeal-planning-decision.service.gov.uk/comment-planning-...
- fdean.gov.uk/media/q1jnfo54/wv-fod-bat-sac-development-ma...
- fdean.gov.uk/planning-and-building/wildlife-and-biodivers...
- fdean.gov.uk/media/sjwf0msn/infrastructure-funding-statem...
- gov.uk/guidance/building-safety-levy-guidance/section-2-l...
- gov.uk/guidance/viability
- gov.uk/guidance/permission-in-principle
What was decided
Forest of Dean District Council refused permission in principle. On 20 July 2026 a planning inspector dismissed the appeal on this point: with no bat surveys, an adverse effect on the protected sites could not be ruled out, so permission in principle could not be given. The Inspector did not go on to consider the location or the number of homes. Read the decision (appeal 6005801).