First pass · LP-196
Land west of Victoria Terrace, Hemingford Road, St Ives, Cambridgeshire
Huntingdonshire District Council (Cambridgeshire), PE27 5HD
It is considered that the field should not be pursued, because all of it lies in Flood Zone 3a and a sequential test across Huntingdonshire would find land at lower risk.
The three blockers
- The whole field is in Flood Zone 3a on the Environment Agency's flood map, and so is the frontage where an entrance off Hemingford Road would go.
- The field lies wholly within the St Ives Conservation Area and adjoins Victoria Terrace, a Grade II listed terrace, whose listed outline comes within about 4 m of its eastern edge.
- The field is countryside under Policy LP10, outside the built-up area that Policies LP7 and LP9 look to for new homes, and inside the Great Ouse Valley green infrastructure priority area.
The site
The evidence behind this page
Every point above, in full, with what would settle it, who settles it, roughly what that costs and where each fact comes from.
The blockers in full
- 1
The whole field is in Flood Zone 3a on the Environment Agency's flood map, and so is the frontage where an entrance off Hemingford Road would go. Policy LP5 of the Huntingdonshire Local Plan to 2036 supports housing only where the sequential test is applied and passed. The Cambridgeshire Flood and Water SPD sets the area of search as usually the whole district, which holds a great deal of land at lower risk. Twenty homes here would have to show no reasonably available site in Flood Zone 1 anywhere in Huntingdonshire, and then pass the exception test as well.
- What would settle it
- Nothing the owner can do changes the flood zone. A site-specific flood risk assessment can show the homes made safe, but it cannot pass the sequential test for them.
- Who settles it
- Huntingdonshire District Council, advised by the Environment Agency, or an Inspector on appeal.
- Rough cost
- over £10,000
Source: huntingdonshire.gov.uk/media/2609/cambridgeshire-flood-an..., read 14 January 2026
- 2
The field lies wholly within the St Ives Conservation Area and adjoins Victoria Terrace, a Grade II listed terrace (list entry 1163068), whose listed outline comes within about 4 m of its eastern edge. The Hemingfords Conservation Area meets its western edge. The conservation area's character assessment of 2007 records ridge and furrow in the fields behind Victoria Terrace, within the green fringe south of the river. In 2016 the council refused one house beside 1 Victoria Terrace (16/00621/FUL), about 180 m east on the same terrace, for harm to that setting and to the conservation area, and for flood risk. No appeal against that refusal was found on the council's register.
- What would settle it
- A heritage statement could weigh the harm, but twenty homes across the whole field cannot be designed to preserve an open setting.
- Who settles it
- Huntingdonshire District Council, advised by its conservation officer, or an Inspector on appeal.
- Rough cost
- £2,000 to £10,000
Source: docs.huntingdonshire.gov.uk/PublicAccess_LIVE/Document/Vi..., read 14 January 2026
- 3
The field is countryside under Policy LP10, outside the built-up area that Policies LP7 and LP9 look to for new homes, and inside the Great Ouse Valley green infrastructure priority area. Natural England's Priority Habitats Inventory maps about 1.02 ha of coastal and floodplain grazing marsh across it. If a habitat survey confirms it, that is a habitat of high distinctiveness for biodiversity net gain. The council's sustainability appraisal of the site also notes the Hemingford Grey Meadow county wildlife site about 200 m to the north-west.
- What would settle it
- A habitat survey would classify the grassland, and a preliminary ecological appraisal and a net gain metric would then measure the loss. If it is grazing marsh, replacing it on or off the land is costly and uncertain.
- Who settles it
- An ecologist, then Huntingdonshire District Council as local planning authority.
- Rough cost
- £2,000 to £10,000
Source: consult.huntingdonshire.gov.uk/kse/event/38343/section/s1..., read 14 January 2026
Sources
- huntingdonshire.gov.uk/media/3872/190516-final-adopted-lo...
- consult.huntingdonshire.gov.uk/kse/event/38343/section/s1...
- huntingdonshire.gov.uk/media/2609/cambridgeshire-flood-an...
- huntingdonshire.gov.uk/media/n3fjbqdc/huntingdonshire-int...
- docs.huntingdonshire.gov.uk/PublicAccess_LIVE/Document/Vi...
- huntingdonshire.gov.uk/media/p2lhfkoj/annual-monitoring-r...
- environment.data.gov.uk/dataset/04532375-a198-476e-985e-0...
- data.gov.uk/dataset/0d6fa1f4-0c82-4c91-8667-a549e8e3ca2d/...
- huntingdonshire.gov.uk/planning/conservation-areas/conser...
- acp.planninginspectorate.gov.uk/ViewCase.aspx?caseid=3277240
- acp.planninginspectorate.gov.uk/ViewCase.aspx?caseid=3349306
- acp.planninginspectorate.gov.uk/ViewCase.aspx?caseid=3276300
- gov.uk/government/publications/local-government-reorganis...
- planit.org.uk/
- planning.data.gov.uk/
- magic.defra.gov.uk/
- gov.uk/government/publications/national-planning-policy-f...
- gov.uk/government/publications/housing-delivery-test-2023...
What the council decided
An application for twenty homes on this field, eight of them affordable, went in on 14 April 2026 with 24 supporting reports. Huntingdonshire District Council refused it on 13 August 2026 on seven grounds. Three of them are the ones this first pass found: the countryside of the Great Ouse Valley outside the built-up area, no sequential test for homes in Flood Zone 3, and harm to the St Ives Conservation Area and its listed buildings. No appeal had been made by 30 October 2026. Read the application (26/00694/FUL).